Investing in Forest Landscape Restoration (FLR):

Investing in Forest Landscape Restoration (FLR):

Challenges and Opportunities

Steve ElliotSteve offers FORRU-CMU's capacity-building services at the ForumIn December 2024, FORRU-CMU presented its capacity-building capabilities at the RESULT Asia-Pacific Investment Forum , in Bangkok, which brought together 72 speakers and 330 participants (both on-location and online), representing governments, NGOs, donors, investors and community groups. The symposium focused on overcoming barriers to financing forest and landscape restoration (FLR) to revive 100 million hectares of degraded land in the Asia-Pacific region by 2030. It was co-organized by leading international organizations including FAO, IUCN, UNDP and UNEP.

With global restoration commitments requiring investment of up to $1,670 billion  over the next decade, the need for sustainable financing solutions has never been more urgent. Speakers highlighted how FLR could transform degraded landscapes into productive and ecologically resilient systems, which could yield impressive returns to investors. However, to realize this potential, entrenched barriers to investment must first be overcome.

Challenges to Funding FLR

NasiDr. Nasi: "Why are we not doing it?"Addressing the plenary session, during the launch of RESULT:Asia-Pacific, Dr Robert Nasi, Chief Operating Officer of CIFOR-ICRAF, stated that an estimated 7-30 US$ in economic benefits could be derived from every dollar invested in restoration and posed the question: "Why are we not doing it?"

Participants in the investment forum identified these key challenges:

  1. High Transaction Costs
    Small projects face disproportionately high transaction costs relative to their size. These fixed expenses discourage investments in smaller, community-led initiatives that are essential to achieving FLR goals.
  2. Limited Private Sector Participation
    Structural challenges such as unclear land tenure, regulatory barriers and the lack of clear financial returns have kept private sector involvement low. Investors seek robust returns, but many FLR projects fail to outline viable profit models.
  3. Community Exclusion
    With less than 1.7 % of climate financing currently ending up in the pockets of small-holder farmers , equitable benefit-sharing mechanisms are long overdue, to ensure sustainability.
  4. Complexity in Carbon and Biodiversity Markets
    While carbon and biodiversity credits hold promise as revenue sources, Lucy Garrett, from the Landscape Finance Lab , explains some of the needs and benefits of landscape financingLucy Garrett, from the Landscape Finance Lab , explains some of the needs and benefits of landscape financingchallenges such as conflicting methodologies, lack of investor trust and low market prices limit their current potential.
  5. Gaps in Technical Capacity
    Governments and community organizations often lack the capacity to implement FLR projects using the latest science-based innovations — the need to adequately budget for capacity building was clear.

Innovative Pathways to Overcome Barriers

Speakers shared various ways to tackle these challenges. Some of the most commonly stated solutions included:

  1. Blended Finance Mechanisms
    Integrating public, private and philanthropic funds can mitigate risks for investors and unlock larger capital flows. Instruments such as green bonds and biodiversity credits are being developed to tie restoration outcomes to market-based returns.
  2. Harm HaverkortMr Harm Haverkort, explains Rabobank's Acorn project Empowering Local Communities
    Various web-based apps were presented to monitor restoration progress and even to enable "blockchain" payments  to ensure transparent and equitable revenue distribution to smallholders. Community engagement was highlighted as a key driver of restoration success. For example, Rabobank’s Acorn Platform illustrated how digital tools and remote sensing can connect smallholders with global carbon markets, via local NGO's, ensuring trust and scalability.
  3. Capacity Building and Training
    Scaling up FLR requires investment in human capital. Training programs for local stakeholders, including technical and financial skills, were highlighted as critical to make restoration projects viable and impactful.
  4. Policy and Governance Reforms
    Streamlining land-tenure laws and incorporating FLR into national policies were seen as essential to create an enabling environment for investments.
  5. Long-Term Sustainability Models
    Designing projects with clear, diverse and adaptable revenue streams, blending agroforestry with non-timber forest products, eco-tourism, carbon income etc. ensures both environmental and economic viability over decades.

Projects seeking investment:

The forum provided an opportunity for proponents of 11 projects from various Asian countries to pitch their proposals directly to potential investors:

Bhutan: Rangeland Restoration

Karma Chorten Dendup, Forestry Officer, Bhutan’s Ministry of Forest and Park Services, presented a project targeting 400,000 acres of degraded rangelands. Activities include erosion control, invasive species removal, water management and prescribed burning. The project aims to support 5,000 households, improve ecosystem services and enhance livelihoods through sustainable rangeland management.

Lao PDR: Mixed-Species Plantations

Soukphavanh Sawathvong, Deputy Head of Planning, Lao Department of Forest, outlined a project to restore 10,000 hectares of degraded land with mixed-species plantations, to enhance biodiversity, carbon storage and livelihoods, via community nurseries and carbon trading. Potential outcomes include non-timber product income, ecosystem recovery and carbon credits.

Enhancing Sustainable Supply Chains in the Mekong Countries (value chain): Thailand, Vietnam, Lao PDR, Cambodia, Chhun Delux, Enhancing Sustainable Supply Chains in the Mekong Countries - Chhun DeluxMekong: Sustainable Supply Chains

Chhun Delux, Cambodia Forestry Administration, highlighted a Mekong initiative to enhance sustainable supply chains for coffee, tea and non-timber forest products. Targeting 5,000 smallholders, the project seeks to increase incomes, facilitate fair market access and foster environmental stewardship. Activities include capacity building, fair trade certification and stakeholder collaboration, with scalability across the region.

Timor-Leste: Transboundary Agroforestry

Catur Basuki Setyawan, Indonesia’s Forestry Ministry and Adelino Do Rojario, Timor-Leste Forestry Directorate, proposed restoring the Talau-Loes watershed with agroforestry. The $13 million project combines bamboo and fruit trees to rehabilitate land, build community capacity and enhance cross-border collaboration to achieve both economic and ecological resilience.

Key Takeaways

  1. Leverage Blended Finance: Encourage partnerships between governments, private investors, and philanthropic donors to reduce risks and attract funding.
  2. Prioritize Local Benefits: Empower smallholders and local communities through equitable benefit-sharing systems.
  3. Invest in Capacity Building: Equip stakeholders with technical, financial and management skills and knowledge bases.
  4. Innovate Carbon and Biodiversity Markets: Develop robust valuation methodologies and frameworks, to unlock the potential of emerging credit markets.

Conclusion

The RESULT Asia-Pacific Investment Forum underscored the monumental task of restoring forest to 100 million hectares of degraded land by 2030. It also shone a light on the immense opportunities available, if stakeholders can overcome financial and technical hurdles. With the right innovations, investments and networks, FLR could become a cornerstone of a sustainable future in the Asia-Pacific Region. On-location participants in the RESULT Investment Forum - many more joined onlineOn-location participants in the RESULT Investment Forum - many more joined online

For more information, please contact RESULT Asia-Pacific at RESULT-Asia-Pacific@fao.org

Stephen Elliott 15/12/24